Commercial Loans and Fun Blog

Commercial Second Mortgages and the New-Money-to-Old-Money Ratio

Posted by George Blackburne on Thu, Feb 8, 2018

Second mortgage-1.jpgYou don't see many new second mortgages on commercial properties these days.  The reason why is because most modern first mortgage loan documents contain an outright prohibition against any sort of junior financing.  It's not just conduits that prohibit junior financing.  Commercial banks now also prohibit junior financing.

The section of a first mortgage that prohibits junior financing is called the alienation clause.  An alienation clause is one that says that the alienation (transfer) of any interest in the property, without the permission of the lender, is grounds to accelerate the loan and to demand that the loan be immediately paid in full.  The really sucky part of such an acceleration is that the payoff demand will contain the full prepayment penalty!  Ouch.

 

Apply For a Commercial  Second Mortgage

 

Putin.jpg

 

"But George, what if there is tons of equity in the property?"

One way a big-time investor can pull equity out of an underleveraged commercial property is to obtain a mezzanine loan.  Unfortunately mezzanine loans and preferred equity investments are also considered junior financing and are usually prohibited.  In some cases, however, an intercreditor agreement can be negotiated.

 

Earn 7% to 12%  Interest

 

Meth.jpg

 

An intercreditor agreement is an agreement between a first mortgage holder and the provider of junior financing, which could be a second mortgage lender, a mezzanine lender, or a preferred equity investor.  The first mortgage lender looks at the junior lender for experience in actually operating the type of property involved and for his financial strength.  If the junior lender is a newbie with no financial strength, the first mortgage lender will say no.  If the junior lender is an old pro with deep pockets, the first mortgage lender will sometimes agree in writing to permit the junior financing.  There is often a provision that says that the first mortgage lender will notify the junior lender immediately in the event of a default.  The intercreditor agreement will also often allow the junior creditor to buy the first mortgage in the event of a default.

 

Submit Your Loan to 750 Commercial   Lenders Using C-Loans.com.  It's Free!

 

Boiling.jpg

 

Okay, with this long-winded background in mind, we finally get to the point of today's training lesson.  This week a buddy of mine who makes preferred equity investments (like a second mortgage but with no required monthly payments) sent out a tombstone.  He proudly announced that his company had just made a second mortgage of $1.4 million behind a $32 million first mortgage on a $50 million shopping center in Kansas City.

Holy crap!  A second mortgage of only $1.4 million behind a $32 million first mortgage???  So I wrote to him, "My friend, this loan grossly violates the New-Money-to-Old-Money Ratio."

 

Free Mortgage Broker  Fee Agreement

 

Breakfast Cat.jpg

 

Back in the old days of hard money, second mortgage lenders learned the hard way never to make a small second mortgage behind a huge first mortgage.

Example:

Newbie Mortgage makes a $20,000 second mortgage behind a $500,000 first mortgage on a house worth $1 million.  There is tons of equity.  Then the borrower becomes a crack addict and stops making all payments.  By the time the second mortgage finds out, the first mortgage is behind 7 payments of $4,000.  Just to cure the loan, Newbie Mortgage has to come up with $28,000.

Then Newbie Mortgage is facing another nine-month ordeal to march to a trust deed sale and to obtain relief from the automatic stay of bankruptcy.  That’s another $36,000.  And then there are attorneys fees and foreclosure costs.  That’s an advance of over $54,000 - just to protect an original investment of $20,000.

Ninety percent of similar investors, in real life, end up just walking away from their $20,000 loan.

 

Get a Free Commercial Mortgage Marketing Course

 

Soft Tacos.jpg

 


The Irony: 

The first mortgage lender goes to a foreclosure sale.  No one bids, so the first mortgage investor ends up owning the property.  After a $15,000 clean-up and facelift, the lender ends up later selling the property for $1.3 million.  Arghh.

New-Money-To-Old-Money Ratio

New Money / Old Money > 33%

In plain English, the wise second mortgage investor will avoid making any second mortgage where this ratio is less than 33%.  In other words, the second mortgage should be at least one-third the size of the first mortgage for the reasons explain above.

 

Free Directory of 750+  Commercial Real Estate Lenders

 

Sandwhich.jpg

 

Now back to my buddy's deal:  Let's compute his New-Money-to-Old-Money Ratio.

($1.4 million / $32 million) x 100% = 4.3%

Holy crap!  This ratio is never supposed to be less than 33%.

Now my buddy is pretty sophisticated and he pointed out that his Fund had negotiated a very good Intercreditor Agreement.  The underlying first mortgage holder had agreed to notify them immediately in the event of a default.

 

Free $549 Training Course

 

Adopted.jpg

 

In addition, his Fund had the option to purchase the underlying first mortgage in the event of a default.  His Fund would love to own this $32 million first mortgage because it had an attractive default interest rate.  It would also love-love-love to own this gorgeous shopping center for a mere $32 million.

He had also gotten personal guarantees from the high net worth borrower and other high-equity LLC's.  Lastly, the shopping center had a number of long-term leases from credit tenants and near-credit tenants.

By the end, I agreed that his was a reasonably prudent investment, but only because his Fund had deep-deep pockets.

 

Nine-Hour Video Training Course  How to Broker Commercial Loans

 

Become a Hard Money Lender.  Approve Your Own Deals!

 

Amazon Drones-1.jpg

 

Folks, I have done a pretty smart thing.  I have started to trade my wonderful video training courses  to mortgage brokers all across the country for a list of ten bankers making commercial loans.  We are adding these banks to CommercialMortgage.com ("CMDC") in huge handfuls.  Man, CMDC is getting soooo useful.  And its free!

 

Free List of 3,159 Commercial Lenders  Sort By Your Own Criteria

 

Get Both Video Training   Programs For Just $849.

 

Subscribe To Blog

 

 

Topics: New Money to Old Money Ratio

New-Money-to-Old-Money Ratio for Commercial Loans

Posted by George Blackburne on Mon, Aug 19, 2013

This article is the fourth in my series on commercial second mortgages.  In my first article I pointed out that commercial second mortgages are rare because most commercial second mortgage lenders got wiped out in the real estate depression of 1987 to 1991.

Apply For a Commercial Loan to Blackburne & Sons

In my second article I pointed out that most bank commercial first mortgage loans have a due-on-the encumbrance clause, making it very risky for commercial lenders to make commercial second mortgages.  In my third article I pointed out even mezzanine loans were difficult because modernly most bank commercial loan documents contained an alienation clause, which forbids even mezzanine loans.

Free List of 3,159 Commercial Lenders  Sort By Your Own Criteria

In this article we will talk about the relative size of the second mortgage compared to the first mortgage.  For the reasons I will outline here, it is imprudent for a commercial lender to make a second mortgage that is too much smaller than the underlying first mortgage. 

The New-Money-to-Old-Money Ratio holds that the ratio of the second mortgage to the first mortgage should never be smaller than 1:3.  In this ratio, the new second mortgage is the "new money", and the existing first mortgage is the "old money".

Why?  Suppose a second mortgage lender made a $200,000 commercial second mortgage behind a $1.5 million first mortgage.  Remember, if a borrower defaults on his first mortgage, the second mortgage holder has to keep the first mortgage current while he forecloses; otherwise, the second mortgage holder risks being wiped out by a foreclosure of the underlying first mortgage.

Now suppose the borrower defaults on both the first and second mortgages.  The second mortgage lender would have to keep the first mortgage current.  For this example, let's suppose the monthly payments on the underlying first mortgage were $15,000 per month.  If the foreclosure took 18 months*, the second mortgage holder would have to advance 18 monthly payments of $15,000 or a whopping $270,000 - just to protect a tiny $200,000 second mortgage.  Yikes!  In real life, most second mortgage lenders would just walk away.

So what would be a more reasonable second mortgage?  The New-Money-to-Old-Money Ratio suggests that the first mortgage should never be more than three times larger than the proposed first mortgage.  In our example, the first mortgage is $1.5 million.  Therefore the smallest second mortgage that would be economically justifiable would be $500,000.  Most lenders would advance $270,000 to protect $500,000.

*  Above I mentioned that the foreclosure might take 18 months.  Many states use mortgages, rather than deeds of trust.  In a mortgage foreclosure, the process has to take place in court.  Courts can often be backed up and extremely slow.  If the subject property is located in a trust deed state - like California or Arizona - the foreclosure process does not involve the courts and is usually much faster.

In addition, many times a second mortgage lender doesn't realize that the borrower has defaulted on the underlying first mortgage until the borrower is four to five months behind on the first mortgage.  The second mortgage holder would have to cure the first mortgage before he even starts his foreclosure, if he wants to keep the first mortgage lender's late charges, default interest, and legal fees to a minimum.  Yikes!

Lastly, if the property enjoys protective equity, a great many borrowers will file a Chapter 11 Bankruptcy to delay the foreclosure sale.  This means even more months of keeping the first mortgage current.

Later in the week we will talk about preferred equity and then later equity, a fairly sophisicated subject.

If you are enjoying this series of articles, how about giving your old buddy a "Like" above?  Thanks!

Click me

Submit Your Loan to 750 Commercial   Lenders Using C-Loans.com.  It's Free!

Topics: New Money to Old Money Ratio